Documents / Hearing transcript

Symposium on unidentified flying objects: hearings before the Committee on Science and Astronautics, U.S. House of Representatives, Ninetieth Congress, second session, July 29, 1968.

U.S. House of Representatives · 1968-07-29 · 256 pages · text from the file's own layer

This is the printed record of a July 29, 1968 symposium on unidentified flying objects held by the Committee on Science and Astronautics of the U.S. House of Representatives, chaired by Rep. J. Edward Roush. The committee heard statements from six scientists: J. Allen Hynek, James E. McDonald, Carl Sagan, Robert L. Hall, James A. Harder and Robert M. L. Baker. It also printed papers from Donald Menzel, Stanton Friedman, Frank Salisbury and others. Hynek argued that puzzling UFO reports from competent witnesses deserve serious scientific study.

  • p. 18 …Some of these statements which lead to mis- conceptions are: —(1) Only UFO "buffs" report UFO…
  • p. 19 …One great misconception is that only UFO buffs report UFO's; quite the opposite is the…
  • p. 25 …saw their very impressive and sur- prising UFO files, the pattern of which is entirely different…
  • p. 39 …files and modes of operation of both private and official (i.e., Project Bluebook) UFO investigative…
  • p. 41 …Misinter- preted natural phenomena (Hypothesis 3) do explain many sincerely -submitted UFO reports; but, as I…
  • p. 45 …It summarizes about 750 UFO cases in the NICAP files up to about
  • p. 46 …Reference 7 is another now -accessible source of extremely significant UFO documentation; it is unfortunate that…
  • p. 54 …Longview, Wash., July 8, 1949 Many of the UFO cases I am citing are drawn intentionally…
  • p. 60 54 terrestrial hypothesis for UFOs, incomprehensibility must be expected as almost inevitable. Hence there is more…
  • p. 63 …NICAP files. The article, by Post reporter Jimmie Woods, represents one of those rare UFO feature…
  • p. 68 …5) remarks that an astronomer working under con- tract to the official UFO investigatory program interviewed…
  • p. 70 …UFO sightings by meteorologists could be extended very con- siderably by drawing on my file of…
  • p. 72 …the UFO problem in the ensuing two-year period. Many details from the official file on…
  • p. 75 …In my files are many other "balloon" cases from the past twenty years, cases that ought…
  • p. 76 …The third target was spotted visually by myself," Hemphill's signed statement in the case -file…
  • p. 78 …25), who evidently drew his information from the official files. Ruppelt (Ref. 5) states that when…
  • p. 79 …unknowns in official files to be ignored. A famous case in UFO annals involved a B…
  • p. 86 …explanations for classic UFO cases that have been made in the official files in the last…
  • p. 91 …Official file on October 15, 1948 Fukuoka case, Project Bluebook. 43. Melbourne (Australia) Sun, December 16…
  • p. 120 …During that night, and several succeeding nights, there were many reports of UFO's over northern…
  • p. 128 …THE UFO PROPULSION PROBLEM By way of introducing the propulsion problem of UFO's, I will…
  • p. 185 179 rod N.T.TuDE tOURIE 3• MOTION OF UFO SYSTIM a..„. — 73 2.3 2…
  • p. 206 …for a UFO. This viewpoint is absolutely nonsense and the Air Force files bear witness to…
  • p. 207 …But such behavior does not imply, as the UFO addicts argue, the presence of an intelligence…
  • p. 208 …He watches the UFO for a minute or two until it finally disappears. He cannot be…
  • p. 218 …UFO presence. This can be done with existing information. Up- date and upgrade the files with…
  • p. 224 …claimed to have observed a UFO. Interestingly enough the official files con- tain fewer than 12…
  • p. 239 …Indeed, at present the scientific study of the UFO problem is greatly hampered by the circumstance…
  • p. 244 …The dotted line represents "re- liable" sightings in the files of the Aerial Phenomena Research Organization…
  • p. 245 …Many radar sightings of UFO's are on file. In a few cases, a UFO has…
  • p. 247 …He states that he has on file more than 300 UFO sightings prior to the 20th…
•
15
quately studied, using all methods available to modern science, and
that the investigation be accorded a proper degree of scientific respect-
ability and an absence of ridicule so that proper investigations can be
carried out unhampered by matters not worthy of the ideals of scien-
tific endeavor. I might suggest that this could be accomplished by the
establishment, by the Congress, of a UFO Scientific Board of Inquiry,
properly funded, for the specific purpose of an investigation in depth
of the UFO phenomenon.
Secondly,I recommend that the United States seek the cooperation
of the United Nations in establishing a means for the impartial and
free interchange among nations of information about, and reports of,
unidentified flying objects—a sort of international clearinghouse for
the exchange of information on this subject. For, since the UFO
iphenomenon is global, it would be as inefficient to study t without
enlisting the aid of other nations as it would be to study world meteor-
ology by using weather reports from one country alone.
Now,it may be well to remind ourselves at this point,that the UFO
problem may not lend itself to an immediate solution in our time.
The problem may be far more complex than we imagine. Attempts to
solve it may be no more productive than attempts to solve the problem
of the Aurora Borealis would have been 100 years ago.
The cause of northern lights could not have been determined in the
framework of the science of 1868. Scientific knowledge in those days
was not sufficient to encompass the phenomenon.
Similarly, our scientific knowledge today may be grossly insufficient
to encompass the problem posed by UFO's. A profound scientific
obligation exists, nonetheless, to gather the best data possible for
scientific posterity.
To summarize: in the course of 20 years of study of UFO reports
and of the interviewing of witnesses, I have been led to a conclusion
quite different from the one I reached in the very first years of my
work. At first I was negatively impressed with the low scientific con-
tent of UFO reports, with the lack of quantitative data, with the
anecdotal nature of the reports, and especially with the lack of hard-
ware, of unimpeachable photographs, and with the lack of instru-
mental recordings.
I am still aware of the paucity of truly hard-core data—but then,
no effort has really been made to gather it. Nonetheless,the cumulative
weight of continued reports from groups of people around the world
whose competence and sanity I have no reason to doubt, reports in-
volving close encounters with unexplainable craft, with physical effects
on animals, motor vehicles, growing plants, and on the ground, has led
me reluctantly to the conclusion that either there is a scientifically
valuable subset of reports in the UFO phenomenon or that we have
a world society containing people who are articulate,sane, and reputa-
ble in all matters save UFO reports.
Either way,I feel that there exists a phenomenon eminently worthy
of study. If one asks, for what purpose,I can only answer—how does
one ever know where scientific inquiry will lead. If the sole purpose of
such a study is to satisfy human curiosity, to probe the unknown, and
to provide intellectual adventure, then it is in line with what science
has always stood for.

Cases discussed

About this file

Hearing transcript, from the govinfo collection. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is under it. 256 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.