Documents / Hearing transcript

Symposium on unidentified flying objects: hearings before the Committee on Science and Astronautics, U.S. House of Representatives, Ninetieth Congress, second session, July 29, 1968.

U.S. House of Representatives · 1968-07-29 · 256 pages · text from the file's own layer

This is the printed record of a July 29, 1968 symposium on unidentified flying objects held by the Committee on Science and Astronautics of the U.S. House of Representatives, chaired by Rep. J. Edward Roush. The committee heard statements from six scientists: J. Allen Hynek, James E. McDonald, Carl Sagan, Robert L. Hall, James A. Harder and Robert M. L. Baker. It also printed papers from Donald Menzel, Stanton Friedman, Frank Salisbury and others. Hynek argued that puzzling UFO reports from competent witnesses deserve serious scientific study.

  • p. 5 …Carl Sagan, associate professor of astronomy, Center for Radiophysics and Space Research, Cornell University 86 Dr…
  • p. 8 …Carl Sagan, Department of Astronomy and Center for RadiophYsics and Space Research, Cornell University; Dr. Robert…
  • p. 91 …Our next participant is Dr.Carl Sagan. Dr. Sagan is associate professor of astronomy in the…
  • p. 92 …CARL SAGAN, DEPARTMENT OF ASTRONOMY, CORNELL UNIVERSITY, ITHACA, N.Y. Dr. SAGAN. Thank you very much…
  • p. 95 …electrical pulses he can't explain? Dr. SAGAN. Yes, sir. There are now five objects in…
  • p. 96 …t that a rather arbitrary statement? Dr. SAGAN. I don't think so. Perhaps you can…
  • p. 98 …UNIDENTIFIED FLYING OBJECTS* (by Carl Sagan) Unidentified flying objects (UFO's) is the generic term for…
  • p. 101 …CARL SAGAN, Department of Astronomy, Cornell University. Thank you. Mr. HECHLER. Dr. Sagan, there have been…
  • p. 102 …trying to do things in Australia? Dr. SAGAN. To the best of my knowledge there is…
  • p. 103 …I believe you coauthored a book with a Russian, is that correct? Dr.SAGAN. That is…
  • p. 104 …say there is extra- terrestrial life? Dr. SAGAN. Yes, sir; it certainly would, but not cinch…
  • p. 113 …one basket. I certainly agree with Dr. Sagan's view that there are these very intense…
  • p. 143 …See, for ex- ample, Shklovskii and Sagan (1966), chapters 27, 28, 30, and 34. (6) Technological…
  • p. 151 …and Sagan C. (1966) Intelligent Life in the Universe, Holden-Day, Inc. San Francisco. 23) Singer…
  • p. 196 …a real free for all. Dr. Sagan. Dr. SAGAN. I just wanted to underline one point…
  • p. 197 191 Dr. SAGAN. That is just what I was going to say. Certain velocity and altitude…
  • p. 199 …barium, although that seems somewhat unlikely. Dr. SAGAN. So some comparison analysis has been made for…
  • p. 203 …McDonald, Dr. Harder, Dr. Hynek, and Dr. Sagan, I believe that you people have made a…
  • p. 225 …R.; Sagan, C., "A Search for Life on Earth at KilometerResolution," Icarus, Vol. 5, January 1966…
  • p. 245 …While Sagan (1963) fails to see any pattern be- cause of the noise, other investigators feel…
  • p. 251 …Cri- terion Books, New York. 285 pp. Sagan, C. 1963. Unidentified flying objects. The Encyclopedia Amen…
134
With respect to "plasma UFO's" Mr. Philip J. Klass (1968b) com-
ments that:
If conditions—all of the conditions—needed to create plasma-UFO's near high-
tension lines or in the wake of jet aircraft occurred readily we should have mil-
lions of UFO reports and the mystery would have been solved long ago. But the
comparative rarity of legitimate UFO sightings clearly indicates that the ball-
lightning related phenomenon is a very rare one.
Even if ball lightning is not the primary source of anomalistic data
(and I am not at present convinced that it is), any program investi-
gating anomalistic observational phenomena would surely shed sig-
nificant light on the ball-lightning problem.
(4) Astronomy.—I have already noted the possibility of cometary
entry, a study of which would be valuable to the astronomer. If as
some respected astronomers believe the anomalistic observational phe-
nomena (including perhaps, "intelligent" radio signals from inter-
stellar space) are the results of an advanced extraterrestrial civiliza-
tion, then the study of the phenomena would become a primary con-
cern of the entire human race. The implications for astronomy are
overwhelming.
(5) Psychiatry and psychology.—Since bizarre events have been re-
ported, the study of eyewitness credibility, under stressful circum-
stances of visual input, if possible. As I will recommend later: if a
competent, mobile task force of professionals could be sent into action
as soon as anomalistic events are detected, then reliable evaluation of
eyewitness reports (soft data) in relation to the actual hard data ob-
tained, could be accomplished. Even if the event was only a spectac-
ular fireball, or marsh gas,the psychiatric/medical examination of eye-
witnesses would still be more informative.
(6) Social science.—Although not classified as a physical science,
there appears to be a challenge here for the social sciences. It has been
my contention throughout this report that it is not a prerequisite to
the study of anomalistic observational phenomena to suppose that they
result from extraterrestrial intelligence.
Nevertheless, it still is an open possibility in my mind. It seems
reasonable, therefore, to undertake a few contingency planning
studies. In order to extract valuable information from an advanced
society, it would seem useful to forecast the approximate characteris-
tics of such a superior intelligence—or, if not necessarily superior, an
intelligence displayed by an industrial,exploratory culture of substan-
tially greater antiquity. There exist dozens of treatises on technologi-
cal forecasting one can key estimates of technological advancement
to speed of travel, production of energy, productivity, ubiquity of
communications, etc. There have been many debates on the technical
capabilities or limits on the capabilities of advanced extraterrestrial
societies (for example,see Markowitz (1967) and Rosa,et al. (1967)).
Often intermixed with these technological capabilities arguments,
however, are very dubious comments concerning the psychological
motivations, behavioral patterns, and unbased projections of the social
motivations of an advanced society. Hypothetical questions are often
raised such as," *"if there are flying saucers around, why don't
they contact us directly? *"I would if I were investigating an-
other civilization." Such comments are made on extremely thin ice,
for, to my knowledge, no concerted study has been carried out in the

Cases discussed

About this file

Hearing transcript, from the govinfo collection. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is under it. 256 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.