Documents / FOIA release

FBI file: Animal Mutilation, Animal Mutilation Part 02

Federal Bureau of Investigation · 25 pages · text by GLM-OCR

This FBI file release, date unknown, reproduces press coverage of cattle mutilations: a magazine report by Ed Sanders and a Newsweek article dated September 30, 1974. The material describes about 1,500 mutilated cattle across 22 states, helicopter sightings, and theories ranging from predators to satanic cults to UFOs. It details a 1975 federal investigation into informants A. Kenneth Bankston and Dan Dugan, whose claims about a satanic cult the investigators came to doubt. It records that the inquiry was then dropped without resolution.

  • p. 1 # The Mutilation Mystery DURING THE PAST THREE YEARS. MORE THAN 1500 CATTLE IN 22 STATES HAVE…
  • p. 2 …some reknown, who had been investigating the cattle mutilations since they first occurred in his home…
  • p. 3 …and that this biker talked about earlier cattle mutilations. The biker also described his experiences in…
  • p. 4 …Tinsley, an employee of the Texas and Southwestern Cattle Raisers Association, who was investigating the mutilations…
  • p. 5 …hovered at night and anusless cattle lay stiff and mutilated in the dawn. Despite the organized…
  • p. 6 …Louis Girodo, about the theory that the mutilations were part of a bacteriological warfare research project…
  • p. 7 THE MUTILATION MYSTERY As far as I have been able to determine, it was investigators in…
  • p. 8 The Colorado Bureau of Investigation officially began its investigation of the mutilations in the summer of…
  • p. 9 …t the mutilators just rent a ranch somewhere and buy a herd of cattle and start…
  • p. 10 …the CIA wants a couple of their cattle—national security, you know—and to please leave…
  • p. 11 THE MUTILATION MYSTERY In Idaho, a man was driving his jeep at about 3:30 A…
  • p. 12 …One researcher, in fact, does claim that the mutilators have got their disease death time down…
  • p. 13 …and boyotes refuse to eat the mutilated horses and cattle. Ben, Schmidt, WM received a Ph…
  • p. 15 …CATTLE MUTILATION FILE: 198-1048 SECTION / OF / THIS SECTION IS COMPRISED OF 96 PAGES WHICH WERE…
  • p. 18 …to look into our jurisdiction over the cattle mutilation problem with which you are concerned. We…
  • p. 19 …Cockburn implies the investigation may have been terminated because cattle mutilation per se is not a…
  • p. 22 …Like myself, he had taken only a passing interest in cattle mutilations. The arrival in June…
  • p. 23 …A survey of newsclips and other literature on cattle mutilation seems to indicate that the whole…
  • p. 24 …What are we left with? In the hundreds of cases of cattle mutilations, no one has…
  • p. 25 …May, more than 100 cattle have been found dead and gruesomely mutilated in Nebraska, Kansas and…

Read from the scan by GLM-OCR; expect the odd misread word.

...

most of them adopted a wait see attitude. And some of the Stateside fugitives had grown downright paranoid after years on the lam. "How do I know they won't lock me up and put me back in the Army?" asked a diehard deserter in New York.

When the Clemency Board-headed by an outspoken critic of the war, former New York Sen. Charles Goodell begins its work, some of the resisters' fears may be eased. Goodell's dovish views will be bolstered by those of other board members, including National Urban League director Vernon E. Jordan and the Rev. Theodore Hesburgh, president of Notre Dame and a former head of the U.S. Civil Rights Commission.

The panelists clearly have some very difficult problems ahead—weighing, for example, time served in jail against time owed for alternate service, or battle honors against time spent AWOL. And the board contained some hawkish members who might oppose leniency, including retired Marine Corps. Gen. Lewis Walt and James Maye, executive director of Paralyzed Veterans of America. Still, the Ford plan had the virtue of all compromises. Said Hesburgh: "As long as Nixon was in, these guys could rot as far as he was concerned. It's the difference between no chance and some chance."

## INDIANS:

Blazing Saddles

It didn't look like much of a border crossing. The sign by the side of the road merely demanded a 10-cent toll from passing motorists, most of whom didn't even stop. But the militant Kootenai Indians manning the roadside picket lines outside Bonners Ferry, Idaho, weren't kidding. After years of frustration trying to deal with Washington, the 67 members of the Kootenai tribe finally lost patience last week and declared war on the United States-by registered mail.

## MYSTERIES:

## The Midnight Marauder

Their challenge was delivered in a letter to President Ford demanding a 128,000-acre reservation, plus as much as $3.2 million for tribal land the government had paid for in 1962 at the rate of 36 cents an acre. To back it up, they threatened to tax white homeowners and businesses squatting on their ancient tribal lands. Idaho's Gov. Cecil Andrus sent in 60 lawmen to keep the highways clear, but tensions soon eased. The Bureau of Indian Affairs invited tribal leaders to begin negotiations, and the citizens of Downers Ferry relaxed. "The Indians have told us that they don't want a war," said one sympathetic local. "They know it's tough for 67 people to get a reaction from Washington, D.C."

Each day, just before dusk, ranchers and farmhands pile into pickup trucks and fan out across the rolling prairie of northeastern Nebraska. They park mostly on ridges or hilltops, where they can scan the pastures and the narrow roads that wind through them. With rilles and shotguns leaning against their trucks, the men watch nervously, smoking cigarettes and talking with each other over a network of citizen's-band radios. Some of the men will stand guard all night, yet none of them really knows what he is looking for. "I've never seen anything

'Warpath': Tribesman soliciting tolls

like this," says State. Sen. Jules Burbach, who has represented Knox County for eighteen years. "Folks are almost hysterical."

Since last May, more than 100 cattle have been found dead and gruesomely mutilated in Nebraska, Kansas and Iowa. On John Sunderman's farm outside Madison, Neb., a cow was killed with a blunt instrument last June and her udder and sexual organs were cut off. When a veterinarian examined the corpse, he found that all of the animal's blood had been drained. On the nearby ranch of Vern Stringfield, a month-old bull calf was clubbed to death. Its blood was drained off, too, and someone cut a hole in the calf's side, removing the intestines and coiling them neatly next to the head.

Rumor and anxiety have produced a host of unproved theories to explain the

bizarre events. Many people, noting that some of the victims were black, suggest that devoters of witchcraft may have done the soul deeds. "It could be someone setting up a fertility cult of some kind," says Richard Thill, a German studies professor at the University of Nebraska who teaches noncredit witchcraft courses, "or it could be someone putting you on. If they are putting you on, they are pretty sick." A few residents report sighting strange creatures resembling bears and gorillas, and at least one farmer claims that a shiny UFO landed in a field where a slaughtered animal was later found.

Rustlers: Still others think the killings may be the work of marijuana smugglers, who supposedly use searchlight-equipped helicopters to harvest the wild stands of pot known to grow in Nebraska. A helicopter often has been seen hovering over the range around the time of a mutilation, and some ranchers swear they have been chased down lonely roads by choppers. Helicopters are also said to have been used in cattle rustling, and some stockmen think the rustlers may be collecting blood and organs as lures for cattle grazing on the open range this fall.

As the tension mounted, law-enforcement officials held statewide conferences to sift the accounts and to calm the rille-toting cattlemen. They organized a posse for a fruitless search of the area. The plot thickened when autopsies were conducted on some of the dead animals. The doctors reported that most of the animals had died of natural causes, such as bacterial infections and kidney disease, or from swallowing oil that had been dropped on the range. Afterward, the medical reports concluded, the carcasses were chewed by predator coyotes, wolves, buzzards, eagles or even magpies.

Cuts: The explanation doesn't suit everyone. "Why didn't we notice this sort of thing in other years?" asks one skeptic. "The predators are not wolves," insists Senator Burbach. "They are a semidomesticated, two-legged animal called man." Noting that many of the cuts seemed to have been done with a blade, Gorden Gruber, an organizer of the patrols, remarked: "I've yet to see a coyote who can chew a straight edge."

Some officials are beginning to worry that the real danger is not some ghostly butcher, but the keyed-up vigilantes themselves. After two slugs pierced the canopy of a utility-company helicopter checking power lines, the Nebraska National Guard ordered its helicopter pilots to cruise cross-country at higher altitudes than usual-generally 2,000 feet instead of 1,000-to avoid being fired upon by frightened ranch hands. "I would hate to think what would happen," a Guard spokesman told Newsweek's William Schmidt, "if one of our pilots was forced to put down a disabled chopper in a pasture at night. Someone might get killed."

Newsweek, September 30, 1974

Cases discussed

About this file

FOIA release, from the fbi-vault collection. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is above. The text was read from the page images by GLM-OCR; expect the odd misread word. 25 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.