Documents / FOIA release

FBI file: Animal Mutilation, Animal Mutilation Part 02

Federal Bureau of Investigation · 25 pages · text by GLM-OCR

This FBI file release, date unknown, reproduces press coverage of cattle mutilations: a magazine report by Ed Sanders and a Newsweek article dated September 30, 1974. The material describes about 1,500 mutilated cattle across 22 states, helicopter sightings, and theories ranging from predators to satanic cults to UFOs. It details a 1975 federal investigation into informants A. Kenneth Bankston and Dan Dugan, whose claims about a satanic cult the investigators came to doubt. It records that the inquiry was then dropped without resolution.

  • p. 1 # The Mutilation Mystery DURING THE PAST THREE YEARS. MORE THAN 1500 CATTLE IN 22 STATES HAVE…
  • p. 2 …some reknown, who had been investigating the cattle mutilations since they first occurred in his home…
  • p. 3 …and that this biker talked about earlier cattle mutilations. The biker also described his experiences in…
  • p. 4 …Tinsley, an employee of the Texas and Southwestern Cattle Raisers Association, who was investigating the mutilations…
  • p. 5 …hovered at night and anusless cattle lay stiff and mutilated in the dawn. Despite the organized…
  • p. 6 …Louis Girodo, about the theory that the mutilations were part of a bacteriological warfare research project…
  • p. 7 THE MUTILATION MYSTERY As far as I have been able to determine, it was investigators in…
  • p. 8 The Colorado Bureau of Investigation officially began its investigation of the mutilations in the summer of…
  • p. 9 …t the mutilators just rent a ranch somewhere and buy a herd of cattle and start…
  • p. 10 …the CIA wants a couple of their cattle—national security, you know—and to please leave…
  • p. 11 THE MUTILATION MYSTERY In Idaho, a man was driving his jeep at about 3:30 A…
  • p. 12 …One researcher, in fact, does claim that the mutilators have got their disease death time down…
  • p. 13 …and boyotes refuse to eat the mutilated horses and cattle. Ben, Schmidt, WM received a Ph…
  • p. 15 …CATTLE MUTILATION FILE: 198-1048 SECTION / OF / THIS SECTION IS COMPRISED OF 96 PAGES WHICH WERE…
  • p. 18 …to look into our jurisdiction over the cattle mutilation problem with which you are concerned. We…
  • p. 19 …Cockburn implies the investigation may have been terminated because cattle mutilation per se is not a…
  • p. 22 …Like myself, he had taken only a passing interest in cattle mutilations. The arrival in June…
  • p. 23 …A survey of newsclips and other literature on cattle mutilation seems to indicate that the whole…
  • p. 24 …What are we left with? In the hundreds of cases of cattle mutilations, no one has…
  • p. 25 …May, more than 100 cattle have been found dead and gruesomely mutilated in Nebraska, Kansas and…

Read from the scan by GLM-OCR; expect the odd misread word.

Makeig at the Fort Worth Star-Telegram had also been receiving letters from two of the informants—convicted armed robbers in the Marion federal prison—and was able to conclude that the federal investigators had become convinced that the informants were putting out a lot of bogus information in an attempt to get moved to prisons from which it would be easier for them to escape. This view was strengthened by the fact that all three informants had indeed made escape attempts.

What are we left with? In the hundreds of cases of cattle mutilations, no one has ever been seen at or near the scene of the crime. No trace of the perpetrators—footprints, car tracks or even evidence of the use of helicopters—has ever been detected. Many ranchers believe that helicopters have been used, partly because a large number of sightings of unidentified helicopters have been reported, partly because it seems this is the only form of transport allowing easy access to remote rangeland. Some investigators believe that such furtive use of helicopters would explain the large number of U.F.O. sightings in the affected states.

Thus ended federal involvement in the investigation of cattle mutilations and thus also ended the last convincing series of leads anyone has yet come up with.

Cynics say that small predators are responsible for many of the alleged mutilations. This may sometimes be the case, but Carl White side, the Colorado Bureau of Investigation officer, told me that out of all the dead animals sent to the veterinary school at Colorado State University six were fresh enough to be amenable to autopsy. One had been the victim of a predator, five had definitely been mutilated by humans. In all cases, he added, the animals had died of natural causes and the mutilations had occurred post-mortem, which he said produced curious questions: "Are the cattle being killed and mutilated by the same people, or do the mutilators come upon them and do the cutting?"

Out of all the investigations only one clue has emerged. In the late summer a Colorado rancher found a blue plastic valise on his land. In it were a cow's tongue, an ear and a scalpel.

The day I spoke with Whiteside he had just returned from a meeting of three hundred ranchers in Kiowa. Elbert County. Elbert County suffered sixty-three cases of mutilation over the summer. Whiteside said the ranchers "were literally up in

arms. . . The thing that' and frightening to them is body can get onto their re actually cut up an animal no trace. What we're afraid we are going to have a ho our hands. A person runs o wanders onto a ranch and thing you know these people spooked become involved i der."

So be careful about road st time you drive around the states. Ed Sanders, who is a an, told me that one of the i driving around mutilation was seeing trucks trundling to orthodox slaughter. You steak for a lifetime and still tated over the fate of one whose organs have been slice unknown cow molesters. It's ironic tension between homi tistics versus humdrum deat roads. As I said at the star question of viewpoint. Crime what you care to see.

And how to solve the case jolly A.T.F. official told me answer is "to get two guys dr as a bull with specially large stand them on the range and It could work, I suppose, but see that the investigators are desperate.

Cases discussed

About this file

FOIA release, from the fbi-vault collection. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is above. The text was read from the page images by GLM-OCR; expect the odd misread word. 25 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.