Defense Intelligence Reference Document Technological Approaches To Controlling

UNCLASSIFIED/)' Pett :SPPll!ltllt '11815 .,.LY
Technological Approaches to Controlling External Devices
in the Absence of Limb-Operated Interfaces
Introduction
Since the advent of modern interactive control of computers, technologies
have been sought to directly connect the biological and the physical to form a
seamless entity. While science fiction explores the possibilities of shared
consciousness between brains and mainframes, real-life scientists work
toward an equally fantastic but more pedestrian goal of eliminating required
electromechanical human-machine interfaces (HMis). Such technologies
promise integration of thought and computer-controlled action, without the
need for a limb-operated device to translate intent from physiological
networks to physical circuits.
This paper first briefly reviews underlying neural structure, function, and
activity to provide background on the type of signals and the scale of temporal
changes that arise from conscious control within the nervous system. A short
primer on brain-machine interfaces (BMis) is included at the end of the
background material. This is followed by a survey of the state-of-the-art
detection and stimulation technologies available utilizing noninvasive and
invasive methods, including several studies that exemplify research paths
currently being undertaken. Discussion brings together elements of the
technology survey, application limitations, a timeline for useful commercial
deployment, and predicted future research directions. Two technology
research paths are highlighted as the most probable to produce functionally
useful devices ( defined as nearly equal or even superior to the control
capabilities of current HM Is) in the near and far term.
The technology endpoint this paper seeks is thought-based operation of
remote machinery during normal human activities without mechanical device
interaction-that is, control of external devices without the need to go to a
specified location, such as a shielded room; without the need to remain
perfectly motionless to reduce signal noise; and without the need for
interaction with a normal electro-mechanical device, such as an i-Phone or
other handheld device with buttons and trackballs. Data transfer rates are
sought to exceed 5-10 bits/second to be useful for operation of complex
devices; this rate range and above is referred to as high-bandwidth BMis.
Response time for a 1-of-N selection of commands is targeted at 300
milliseconds or less. These are the operational parameters assumed for final
implementation unless some limitation or supercapability is described.
The paper concludes that noninvasive electrical monitoring of neural activity,
primarily reading combined action of muscles and neurons, is the most
promising commercial technology in the near term. Inherent limitations in the
noninvasive electrical approach require future development of different
research paths. The paper argues, mainly by eliminating other approaches,
that the most probable technology in the long term involves invasive single-
neuron-based direct cortical connections to form a network of high-bandwidth
duplex communication pathways. Currently the most promising technologies
V
UNCLASSIFIED/ /F8R 8Ffl@Itllt ~31!! :SHE I