Defense Intelligence Reference Document Concepts For Extracting Energy From The Quantum Vacuum

UNCLASSIFIED/ ,'1"1!11'- l!ll"l"ll!lllile lal!i! i;nn,~r
First, one sees that although the original inspiration for the concept of continuous
vacuum energy extraction came from second-quantized QED theory, it must be
acknowledged that QED, as an axiomatic, quantized formalism based on the concept of
an immutable, non-degradable vacuum, does not support the concept of continuous
vacuum energy conversion. Given that second-quantized QED is our most
comprehensive quantum theory to date, its lack of support for continuous vacuum
energy conversion must be given serious consideration.
Second, SED as an alternative theory, whose formalism has been taken to support the
concept of continuous vacuum energy conversion, has enough shortcomings in its
current state of development that one must conclude that it is not at present an
adequate tool for the assessment of potential vacuum energy conversion. SED
predictions must thus remain suspect in the absence of experimental confirmation. The
purpose of the experimental program outlined in Section IV is meant to address this
need.
Third, the concept of the conversion of energy from vacuum fluctuations is in principle
not falsifiable, given the unknowns which present theory has yet to resolve (for
example, cosmological dark energy, multiple vacuum structures), and the numerous
approaches currently being brought to bear in the development of quantum theory.
Finally, even though experimental efforts at energy extraction from the vacuum have
been proposed or are already under way at various laboratories, definitive theoretical
support underpinning the concept of useful extraction of energy from quantum
fluctuations is not yet in place. Such support awaits theoretical developments that
either posits a plenum that (unlike second-quantized QED) can be shown to be
degradable, or posit conversion of energy associated with matter fluctuations, also in a
degradable fashion. Since the quantum fluctuations of interest are associated with
quantum ground states, what is minimally required are particle-vacuum or particle-
particle interactions that result in the formation of alternate lower-energy, ground
states of matter/field configurations. Suggested approaches to be explored are those
which are known to yield results consistent with the existence of vacuum fluctuation
fields, but without the formalism of independently postulated second-quantized vacuum
fields. Whether useful conversion of energy from quantum fluctuations can be
accomplished, and identifying the unequivocal conditions under which this can be
achieved, are yet to be determined.
It has been shown that the QED vacuum is in fact degradable under the action of a
variety of Casimir effects, quantum optical vacuum squeezing, gravitation-induced
vacuum squeezing, or gravitational redshifting. There is also QED vacuum decay via the
critical/supercritical electric fields of superheavy atomic nuclei, X-ray free-electron
lasers, or externally applied (non-critical) magnetic fields. However, it is not known
whether these effects can be exploited for the continuous extraction of useful energy
from the vacuum. The concept of a dual, degradable vacuum structure in QCD can
possibly lead to the generation of useful energy via the release of latent heat from
melting the QCD vacuum.
A game changer may appear that could dramatically accelerate or alter the direction of
theoretical and experimental programs. Such a game changer could entail a complete,
comprehensive unified field theory (that is, a finalized quantum superstring theory, or
some other theory that replaces it), or a completely new theory for the quantum
38
UNCLASSIFIED//f811. 8ffiliii,t.k Wliili O•lk.Y