Documents / FOIA release

USSR: Measures of Economic Growth and Development, 1950-80

Central Intelligence Agency · 1982-12-08 · 399 pages · text from the file's own layer

This Joint Committee Print, dated December 8, 1982, gathers studies that the Central Intelligence Agency's Directorate of Intelligence prepared for the Joint Economic Committee of the US Congress. It gives estimates of Soviet gross national product for 1950 to 1980, with indexes of industrial production, agricultural production and consumption, and explains the methods and data behind them. The foreword says official Soviet statistics inflate growth and that the CIA measures offer a more accurate picture. The document contains no UFO material.

  • p. 36 …In the USSR the collective farm, or kolkhoz, is part state and part cooperative. The land…
  • p. 47 …0.66e_ Consumer cooperatives 1.283 i Retained profits of consumer cooperatives 0.821 Tax on…
  • p. 50 …Hill, The Measurement of Real Product, The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, Paris, 1971; R…
  • p. 103 …Net profits of consumer cooperatives were included with retail trade and public dining. Subsidies. This item…
  • p. 118 …and economic admin- istration, administrative organs of cooperative and social organizations,” for which employment and oth…
  • p. 119 …Social organi- zations include the administrative organs of the All- Union Society of Consumer Cooperatives, the…
  • p. 130 …The profits distributed to consumer cooperative members are now considered to be a transfer receipt rather…
  • p. 133 …Profits distributed to consumer cooperative members 0.027 9. Total income 217.206 Sources to this…
  • p. 134 …Profits distributed to consumer cooperative members. See CIA, GNP I970, p. 23. 9. Total income. This…
  • p. 135 …State, cooperative, and commission sales 141.096 (1)Fo0d 84.104 (2) Soft goods 42.734…
  • p. 137 …Charges paid by members of housing 0.075 cooperatives for maintenance lmputed gross rent on urban…
  • p. 138 …Taxes on land and buildings owned by individuals and cooperatives are from Gosb_vudzhet I972, p…
  • p. 139 …Retained profits of consumer cooperatives 0.821 d. Retained profits of other organizations 0.321 2…
  • p. 142 …Profits distributed to consumer 0.027 cooperative members 8.’C;solidate_d total outlays 215.841…
  • p. 147 …Consumer cooperatives 1.283 (1) Retained profits of consumer cooperatives 0.821 (2) Tax on income…
  • p. 160 …532) plus a share of the amortization deductions of consumer cooperatives. Altough consumer cooperatives are primarily…
  • p. 162 …532) and amortization deductions of consumer cooperatives on industrial capital (0.083 billion ru~ bles-—see…
  • p. 164 …retained profits and income taxes of consumer cooperatives and other organizations, respectively. 7. Total pra/its…
  • p. 257 …Other state purchasing orga- nizations are the Central Union of Consumer Cooper- atives, and the Ministries…
  • p. 286 …Review of I978 and Outlook for I97 9, Economics, Statistics, and Cooperatives Service, April 1979, p…
  • p. 330 …exceeded the prices paid in state and cooperative retail outlets by an average of ~59 percent…
  • p. 331 …index of retail prices in state and cooperative outlets. The index which shows almost no change…
  • p. 332 …In coverage, it differs from the CIA index of consumption, mainly by inclusion of cooperative housing…
  • p. 335 …purchases of these items in state and cooperative retail outlets and in collective farm markets, including…
  • p. 339 …The index implicitly covers all goods purchased in state and cooperative retail out- lets, except those…
Approved for Release: 2019/07/19 C05210421
I-O table because relative producers’ prices are
thought to be more stable over time than relative
purchasers’ prices.
Since Soviet I-O tables show only the productive
sectors,“ while the transportation and communica-
tions sectors furnished both productive (freight trans-
portation) and nonproductive (passenger transporta-
tion) services, these GNP sectors must be
disaggregated. In addition, to obtain a value-added
quadrant in producers’ prices, we must compute: (1)
the implicit subsidies received and turnover taxes paid
by each productive sector on its material purchases,
(2) the nonproductive services purchased by each
sector, and (3) the material purchases of the service
sectors. These estimates are explained in more detail
in appendix E.
The 1970 I-O table is estimated with the help of a
least squares minimization algorithm. It estimates a
1970 I-O table in producers’ prices that is as much
like the actual 1972 table as possible, with the
constraint that each row and column must sum to a
predetermined amount. The row and column sums are
determined as each sector’s gross output less, respec-
tively, its value added or final demand. See appendix
E for further discussion of the algorithm and its
rationale.
Many of the steps taken to compute the 1970 I-O
table in producers’ prices are part of the conversion to
factor-cost prices, notably the elimination of turnover
taxes and subsidies on final goods and services. The
remaining steps eliminate the rest of turnover taxes
and subsidies and replace profits with a uniform
capital charge. In our earlier publication on the 1970
GNP accounts, the uniform capital charge was set at
12 percent of the sum of fixed and working capital.
The present report follows the work of Brown, Hall,
“ The Soviet Union divides its economy into productive and
nonproductive sectors. Productive sectors are those which produce
material goods (industry, construction, and agriculture) and those
which are needed to deliver material goods to their final user
(freight transportation, business communications, and wholesale
and retail trade).
and Licari in applying I-O repricing algorithms,
developed originally for East European I-O tables, to
determine the interest rate.“
The repricing procedure or algorithm relies on a basic
property of an I-O table: that the sum of the entries in
a particular column must equal the sum of the entries
in the corresponding row. That is, a sector’s sales must
equal its total expenses, including profits. This proper-
ty, plus the distribution of each sector’s sales de-
scribed by an I-O table, provides the ability to relate
an increase in the price of the output of one sector to
increases in the costs of all sectors. Thus, equalizing
the rate of return on each sector’s fixed and working
capital implies a given set of changes in relative
prices, and the I-O table can be used to compute
directly the required array of price changes.
A Comparison of Established and Factor-Cost Prices
Tables 10 and 11 compare the percentage distribution
of GNP by end use and by sector of origin, in
established prices and in factor-cost prices. As expect-
ed, the largest difference in the end-use distribution
(table 10) is the increase in the share attributed to
services, especially housing, when factor-cost prices
are used. Expenditures on consumer services, which
were 11.6 percent of GNP in established prices, are
19.5 percent of GNP in factor-cost prices. The hous-
ing share increases from 0.9 to 7.0 percent of GNP.
The shares of most other services also rise.
The major reductions in GNP shares are in consumer
goods, especially beverages, soft goods, and durables.
These changes stem mainly from the elimination of
turnover taxes. As a whole, however, the share of
consumption is about the same in established prices
(55.1 percent) as in factor-cost prices (54.2 percent).
The share of investment is virtually unchanged by the
use of factor-cost prices. Total investment is 28.5
percent of GNP in established prices and 28.2 percent
in factor-cost prices, with the structure almost the
same. '
“’ Alan A. Brown, Owen P. Hall, and Joseph A. Licari, Price
Adjustment Models for Socialist Economies: Theory and Empiri-
cal Technique, International Development Research Center. Bloo-
mington, Ind., 1973.
40
Approved for Release: 2019/07/19 C05210421

Not linked to a story yet.

About this file

FOIA release, from the cia-readingroom collection. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is above. 399 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.