Documents / FOIA release

(Estimated Pub Date) the Challenge of Ethnic Conflict to National and International Order in the 1990S: Geographic Perspectives- October 1995

Central Intelligence Agency · 1995-10-01 · 205 pages · text from the file's own layer

This Central Intelligence Agency conference report, numbered RTT 95-10039 and dated October 1995, presents the proceedings of a conference held 30 September to 1 October 1993. The CIA's Geographic Resources Division sponsored the conference. In it, academic geographers, anthropologists and US Government officials examined ethnic conflict by region, covering Eastern Europe, the former Soviet Union, Africa, Latin America, the Middle East, Asia and South Asia. The report also discusses what these conflicts mean for US policy. It does not deal with UFOs or unidentified aerial phenomena.

  • p. 9 …He also dis- cusses how various groups have reacted to rising terri- torial nationalism. Approved for…
  • p. 18 …The issue of sense of territory is thus closely linked to the second core terri- torial…
  • p. 19 …The latter encompasses laws that set aside some terri- tory for a given ethnic group. The…
  • p. 28 …The link between territory, identity, and terri- toriality becomes especially dynamic when discord exists between two…
  • p. 32 …Murphy made about ethnic mobili- zation and socioeconomic status as they relate to terri- toriality. Dr…
  • p. 33 …suggest giving the old provinces more political-terri- torial significance within the state. Then their citizens…
  • p. 50 …The Serbs want Krajina as a piece of geographical terri- tory, and the Serbs who live…
  • p. 52 …Sovereignty over European terri- tory was initially determined by church and dynastic settlements following periodic warfare…
  • p. 66 …That may mean some of the kinds of terri- torial policies that I suggested. It also…
  • p. 76 …National identity and terri- torial identity have been intimately interrelated, and a rising sense of national…
  • p. 79 …The big- gest threat to Russia today in terms of its intemal terri- torial integrity is…
  • p. 153 …The real crux of the terri- torial problem is one of scale because the homoge- neity…
  • p. 184 …Nevertheless, many geographers will agree that one of the most important characteristics of‘terri- tory is…
Approved for Release: 2018/06/01 C00123268
demands for the return of territories deemed to be
unjustly under the control of foreign groups or states,
and those related to the liberation of coethnics living
in exclave communities in neighboring countries or
regions. In this first category, I include only those
issues in which the Westem powers cannot or should
not become involved, in spite of the fact that they may
result in open warfare. In many of these, however,
diplomatic discussion before the outbreak of hostili-
ties may be useful.
There are six potentially serious local conflicts that
may arise in Eastem Europe that are based on ethnot-
erritorial issues. These include both claims to territo-
ries in other countries that are based on historical
grievances and issues of national liberation of ethnic
minorities living in someone else’s country. Four con-
cem transborder peoples: 1) the Russian minorities in
Ukraine and the Baltic states; 2) the Moldovan ques-
tion, which includes both issues of ethnic rights for
Russians and Ukrainians in Moldova and border
issues between Ukraine and Romania; 3) a possible
secessionist movement in western Ukraine; and 4)
Hungarian minorities in neighboring Slovakia, Serbia,
and Romania. Two involve minority issues: Muslim
minorities living in the former Yugoslav lands and
Bulgaria and ethnic 'I‘urkish minorities in the Balkans.
Russians in Ukraine and the Baltic States
The collapse of the USSR and the declaration of inde-
pendence by the former non-Russian republics has left
millions of Russians outside Russia. Their situation is
debated both locally and in Russia and plays a major
role in the current political relations of Russia and
these states. In a few cases, the issue is not just cul-
tural and ethnic. In the cases of Ukraine and Estonia,
the Russian population has a significant presence on
the border of Russia, and in those two cases (as with
Kazakstan), Russian nationalists are demanding that
these areas be reincorporated into Russia. In eastern
Ukraine and eastern Estonia, this can be even more
serious because these regions are major industrial
areas vital to the economic well-being of these new
republics.
The situation of the Russians in Estonia is serious.
I-Iere the Russian issue is not merely ethnic but also
territorial. On the eastern margins of Estonia one finds
a large Russian population. In the area north of Lake
Peipus (Chudskoe Ozero in Russian) as far as the Bal-
tic Sea, Russians fonn a clear majority of the popula-
tion. Indeed, Narve is a Russian city in Estonia. There
is a great potential for a Russian attempt to secede
from Estonia and join Russia itself. This would lead to
a great deal of conflict. Most of these Russians do not
represent the descendants of early Russian immigrants
to Estonia but rather part of the huge Russian popula-
tion that arrived after World War II.
In Latvia, Russians—when combined with Belorus-
sians and Ukrainians—-account for slightly less than
half the country's population. In Riga, Slavs far out-
number native Latvians. In both Latvia and Estonia, as
well as in neighboring Lithuania (where the Slavs
compose only about 20 percent of the population),
there is a fear that Russia may use the presence of
these significant Russian minority populations as a
pretext (i.e., a justification) to reincorporate these
small countries into a new Russian-dominated state.
In Estonia, Latvia, and-—to a lesser extent——Lithuania,
local governments are devising various forms of legis-
lation to induce the Russians to leave. Although it is
reasonable for Estonians and Latvians to demand that
citizens learn the local language and swear allegiance
to those countries—-as all nations of the world demand
allegiance to the new homeland to obtain citizen-
ship—it is clear that the two states desire to get rid of
the Russians. Open hostility toward or attacks upon
Russians will provoke problems with Russia, so it is
left to a game of politics. This could escalate into a
serious conflict with Russia, especially if a Russian
nationalist govemment arises in Moscow. Regardless
of how this goes, it is clear that the United States and
its Western allies cannot and should not do anything in
the event of such a showdown. On the other hand, the
West’s inaction in the Croatian and Bosnian conflict
may play a great role in increasing hostilities and con-
flicts in the Baltic region. This is discussed later in this
paper.
The Moldovan Question
Upon declaring independence from the USSR, Mold-
ova found itself in a unique position among the former
27
Approved for Release: 2018/06/01 C00123268

Not linked to a story yet.

About this file

FOIA release, from the cia-readingroom collection. The PDF is mirrored here; the original link is above. 205 pages are in the text index: search them above, or from the library's search.